Wana Pizza
← All articles 7 Best Pizza Places in La Porte Indiana Ranked blog

7 Best Pizza Places in La Porte Indiana Ranked

Last Updated: November 7, 2026

Quick Summary

The best pizza in la porte in Indiana is Wana Pizza, a local spot known for hand-tossed crust, signature sweet sauce, and a garlic butter finish that holds up on the drive home. It is a strong pick for families and groups who want custom orders, with five Northwest Indiana locations including La Porte.

  • Wana Pizza makes its dough fresh in stores from unbleached flour with no potassium bromate.
  • Aurelio's Pizza of LaPorte serves a thin crust with a distinctly sweet, tomato-forward sauce.
  • Jet's Pizza builds Detroit-style square pies with eight corner pieces per pie.
  • Aurelio's La Porte location at 2330 N. Highway 35 opens 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. most days.
  • Carryout is almost always faster and hotter than delivery if you can grab it yourself.
Craving the best pizza in La Porte?Wana Pizza serves hand-tossed pies with sweet sauce and garlic butter crust, delivered hot.
Order Wana Pizza Now

Table of Contents

How We Picked the Best Pizza in La Porte Indiana

Finding the best pizza in la porte in Indiana comes down to more than a star rating. At Wana Pizza, we built this shortlist on four things: verified local listings, consistent customer feedback, the range of styles each kitchen offers, and how easy it is to actually get the pie in your hands, whether that means dine-in, carryout, or delivery.

Ratings from review sites are a useful starting point, but ratings alone do not tell you whether the crust holds up on the drive home or whether a Friday night pickup takes twenty minutes or fifty.

So we scored each spot on the details that matter when you are hungry: crust quality, topping range, ordering convenience, and value. Below, we'll show you exactly how each local favorite stacks up, plus what most "best pizza" roundups leave out.

Quick Comparison: Top Pizza Spots at a Glance

Here is the short version before we get into the details. Every spot below earned its place for a different reason, so match the pick to your night.

Pizza Spot Style Best For Ordering
Wana Pizza Hand-tossed, sweet sauce, garlic butter crust Families, groups, custom orders Online, phone, delivery, carryout
Aurelio's Pizza Thin crust, signature sauce Sit-down dinners, local tradition Dine-in, carryout, delivery
Albano's Villa Classic pies, local favorite Downtown walk-in meals Dine-in, carryout
J&J's Pizza Shack Thin crust, casual pies Quick lunch, takeout Carryout, delivery
Marco's Pizza Chain-style specialty pies Predictable chain experience Delivery, carryout
Jet's Pizza Detroit-style square pies Deep-dish cravings, group orders Delivery, carryout
Wana Pizza (Michigan City) Same hand-tossed menu Nearby delivery across the area Online, phone, delivery

That table is the fast answer. The rest of this guide explains why each one made the cut.

The Best Pizza in La Porte Indiana Delivery and Carryout

If you want the best pizza in la porte in Indiana delivery and carryout, the deciding factor is not the menu. It is whether the pie arrives hot and intact. Most roundups list delivery as a checkbox; here is how the local options actually differ once the box leaves the counter.

Delivery quality comes down to three practical things: how far the driver travels, how the pizza is boxed, and how busy the kitchen is when your order lands. A thin crust that sits in a box for twenty minutes steams and softens. A hand-tossed crust with a garlic butter finish holds up better on the road. That is why the same pizza can taste great in the dining room and mediocre on your couch.

Here is how the main carryout and delivery options compare on the details that matter:

  • Wana Pizza: Hand-tossed crust and garlic butter finish travel well. Contact the restaurant to ask about delivery and carryout options.

A few local mechanics are worth knowing before you order:

  • Distance beats rating. A spot four minutes away usually beats a better-rated spot twenty minutes out. Ask which store is dispatching your order, not just which brand you are calling.
  • Boxing matters. Ventilated boxes and a liner under the pie reduce sogginess. Thin crust needs this more than hand-tossed.
  • Timing matters. Order before the dinner rush, not during it, for a faster window.
  • Carryout is almost always faster and hotter if you can grab it yourself. Pickup also lets you check the pie before you leave.

If you are comparing nearby options, our Best Pizza Delivery in Michigan City: 2026 Guide covers the same questions for the next town over.

Watch out: a quoted delivery time is an estimate, not a promise. If the kitchen is slammed, a thin-crust pie can sit in the warmer long enough to lose its edge, so confirm the window when you order.

Best Pizza in La Porte Indiana Downtown: Walkable Slices and Local Favorites

Downtown La Porte has a range of pizza options for walk-in diners. Here is how to think about the styles and whether a room fits your group.

Local listings show a mix of independent pizza spots rather than one dominant chain, so variety is the main theme downtown. Here is how to match the room and the pie to your night.

Match the style to the craving.

  • Hand-tossed with a garlic butter finish: Wana Pizza is the hand-tossed option, with a sweet sauce and a crust that holds up better on the drive home. Best for families and groups who want custom orders.

Signature pies to order first. Wana Pizza's regulars come back for the hand-tossed crust, signature sweet sauce, and garlic butter edge. If you are ordering for a table, pairing a thin crust with a hand-tossed pie can cover both the crisp crowd and the chewy-crust crowd.

Seating and group suitability. Check with each restaurant about seating before you go, especially for a larger group. Wana Pizza's own dine-in and carryout options are best confirmed directly with the store.

Timing. Downtown spots fill up fast at midday, so go early for lunch. For dinner, check opening hours before you go. Aurelio's lists its La Porte location at 2330 N. Highway 35, with hours of 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday, according to Aurelio's official location page.

Dietary and allergen questions. If you need gluten-free, vegetarian, or vegan options, call the kitchen before you order to confirm what is available.

Jet's Pizza La Porte Menu: What to Expect from the Chain Option

The Jet's Pizza La Porte menu is built around Detroit-style square pizza: thick, rectangular, with cheese that runs to the edges and caramelizes against the pan. If you want a deep, saucy, filling pie, that is the draw.

What to expect from a chain option like this:

  • Consistency: The recipe is the same across locations, so you know what you're getting.
  • Square slices: Eight corner pieces per pie, which makes portioning for a group simple.
  • Specialty toppings: A broad list, including several meat-heavy combinations.
  • Delivery focus: Chains are set up for delivery and carryout rather than long sit-down meals.

The trade-off is character. A chain pie is reliable, but it is not the local flavor you get from an independent kitchen. If you grew up on a specific sauce or crust style, a chain will not match it.

Aurelio's Pizza of LaPorte Menu: A Local Institution's Signature Pies

The Aurelio's Pizza of LaPorte menu carries a name that has been part of Northwest Indiana pizza for decades. The signature is a thin crust with a distinctly sweet, tomato-forward sauce, a style that has built a loyal following across the region.

What stands out on this menu:

  • Thin crust: Crisp, light, and built for sharing.
  • Signature sauce: Sweeter than most, which is the dividing line for some diners.
  • Classic toppings: Sausage, pepperoni, and veggie combinations done the traditional way.
  • Dine-in experience: A sit-down setting that suits families and groups.

Aurelio's sits at a highway location, which makes it an easy stop for carryout on the way home. The one drawback is that a thin crust does not travel as well as a hand-tossed one, so eat it there or pick it up yourself when you can.

Beyond the Chains: Why Wana Pizza Belongs on Your Shortlist

A hand-tossed pizza with stretching cheese being served, representing the best pizza in La Porte in Indiana.
A hand-tossed pizza with stretching cheese being served, representing the best pizza in La Porte in Indiana.

Here is where the local shortlist gets interesting. Wana Pizza earns a spot on this list because of how the dough is made, not because of a marketing budget.

Our dough is made fresh in our stores from unbleached flour with no potassium bromate, using just flour, water, yeast, sugar, and salt, which you can read about on our Better Flour.Better Crust. page. That is the foundation. The hand-tossed crust comes out light and airy with a crisp edge, and the signature sweet sauce and garlic butter crust are what regulars come back for.

One customer from Peoria put it plainly: "The hand-tossed dough melts in your mouth --light, airy and crispy on the edges."

We run five Northwest Indiana locations: La Porte, Michigan City, Hebron, Wanatah, and Kouts, according to Wana Pizza's location list. That spread matters for delivery, because a closer kitchen means a hotter pie.

Best for: Families and groups who want custom orders and a crust that holds up on the drive home. Skip if: You specifically want a thick Detroit-style square pie.

Order Your Next Pizza Night from Wana Pizza

Picking a pizza spot is really a question of what your night needs. A quick lunch downtown, a deep-dish craving, or a family dinner where everyone wants something different, each one points to a different kitchen.

If you want a hand-tossed pie with a garlic butter crust and a sauce that tastes like something, Wana Pizza is built for exactly that. Browse our full menu with prices to see the specialty pies and build-your-own options, or use our party calculator to work out how much pizza to order for an office lunch or birthday. Still have questions about delivery, hours, or gluten-free crust? Our FAQ page has the answers.


The gap between a good pizza night and a disappointing one usually comes down to the crust and the timing. Wana Pizza makes dough fresh in-store daily, finishes every pie with a signature sweet sauce and optional garlic butter crust, and runs delivery and carryout from five Northwest Indiana locations so your order arrives hot. Get started with Wana Pizza and turn tonight's dinner into the easy part of your day.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best pizza places in La Porte, Indiana?

Local favorites include Wana Pizza for its hand-tossed dough and sweet sauce. The best pizza in La Porte Indiana depends on whether you want dine-in, delivery, or a specific crust style, so compare menus and hours before ordering.

Where can I get pizza delivery in La Porte?

Several pizza places in La Porte offer delivery and carryout, including Wana Pizza and other local spots. Delivery times vary by location and order volume, so call ahead or order online for the best pizza in La Porte Indiana delivery. Wana Pizza serves La Porte and nearby Northwest Indiana communities, and you can confirm your delivery window when you order. For hot, fresh pizza, ask about the estimated arrival time and any delivery minimums.

Does Aurelio's Pizza in La Porte have a menu online?

For information about Aurelio's Pizza of LaPorte, including its menu and hours, please contact the restaurant directly.

What pizza styles are available in La Porte?

Wana Pizza is known for hand-tossed dough, a signature sweet sauce, and a garlic butter crust. If you have dietary restrictions, contact the restaurant to ask about your options. The best pizza in La Porte Indiana for you will depend on whether you prefer a cracker-thin crust, a chewy hand-tossed bite, or a loaded specialty pie.

GoogleAdd wanapizza.com as a preferred source on Google →