blog
7 Top-Rated Pizza Places in Indiana Worth the Drive
Quick Summary
The top rated pizza places in Indiana depend on the crust, sauce and takeout quality you want, and Indiana has several regional styles. In Northwest Indiana, Wana Pizza serves LaPorte, Wanatah, Hebron, Kouts and Michigan City with hand-tossed dough, a signature sweet sauce and a garlic butter crust. Confirm hours and service modes before you drive.
- Wana Pizza serves Northwest Indiana, including LaPorte, Wanatah, Hebron, Kouts and Michigan City.
- Wana Pizza uses hand-tossed dough, a signature sweet sauce and a garlic butter crust.
- Choose a pizza style first: thin crust for sharing, deep dish for a hungry crowd.
- Before ordering, ask about delivery times, crust customization and wrong-order policies.
Table of Contents
- How We Chose These Top Rated Pizza Places in Indiana
- Best Pizza Places in Indianapolis
- Top-Rated Pizza Places in Indiana Near Me: Statewide Picks Beyond the Capital
- Matching Your Pizza Style: Thin Crust, Deep Dish and Wood-Fired
- Northwest Indiana Favorites: Where Wana Pizza Fits In
- Takeout, Delivery and Dietary Options at Indiana Pizzerias
- Order Your Next Favorite Slice From Wana Pizza
- Frequently Asked Questions
How We Chose These Top Rated Pizza Places in Indiana
We looked at what makes a pizza place worth a trip: the crust, the sauce, the consistency of the product and whether the food holds up when it's packed for takeout. We also weighed how well each option suits different needs, from a quick lunch to a family dinner or a group order. Our selection is an editorial judgment, not a formal ranking, and we have not verified every restaurant's current ratings, hours or menu. Check each business directly before you go.
Best Pizza Places in Indianapolis
Indianapolis has a wide range of pizza styles, and pizza places there are often grouped by neighborhood and by style. Rather than send you across the metro on a guess, use this section as a decision framework: match the neighborhood you are already in to the style you actually want, then confirm hours and service mode directly with the restaurant before you drive.
Downtown and Mass Ave.
Broad Ripple and SoBro.
Fountain Square and Irvington.
Northside and Carmel-adjacent corridors.
Southside and Greenwood-adjacent corridors.
Before you order from any pizzeria, confirm whether it offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery, ask about crust customization, and check current hours on the day you plan to visit.
Top-Rated Pizza Places in Indiana Near Me: Statewide Picks Beyond the Capital
Searching for top-rated pizza places in Indiana near me works best when you widen the map and understand that the state does not have one pizza culture, it has several. Pizza styles vary across Indiana, from crust to topping choices. The picks below are organized by region so you can find the right shop for where you actually are, not just the closest one to the capital.
How these picks were selected. This is an editorial guide, not a paid ranking. Where a shop's hours, service modes, or menu change seasonally, confirm directly before you go.
Northern Indiana. Wana Pizza serves the Northwest Indiana corridor, including LaPorte, Wanatah, Hebron, Kouts, and Michigan City, with hand-tossed dough, a signature sweet sauce, and a garlic butter crust.
Practical details to confirm before you order. Ask each shop whether it offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery, whether the crust can be customized for gluten-sensitive diners, how long delivery takes during your time slot, and what its policy is if an order arrives wrong.
Matching Your Pizza Style: Thin Crust, Deep Dish and Wood-Fired
Not every pizza suits every craving. Thin crust is light and crisp, which works well for sharing. Deep dish is dense and filling, a good choice for a hungry crowd. Hand-tossed crust sits between the two, with an airy interior and a chewy, golden edge. Wood-fired pies pick up a smoky char. Decide which of these you want before you choose a restaurant, and check the menu for the style you're after.
Each style suits a different craving, so here is how the main options compare.
| Style | Texture | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Thin crust | Light and crisp | Sharing |
| Deep dish | Dense and filling | A hungry crowd |
| Hand-tossed | Airy inside, chewy golden edge | A middle ground |
| Wood-fired | Smoky char | Smoky flavor |
Northwest Indiana Favorites: Where Wana Pizza Fits In
Wana Pizza serves Northwest Indiana with hand-tossed dough, a signature sweet sauce and a garlic butter crust. Local residents in Wanatah, Hebron, LaPorte, Kouts and Michigan City prefer fresh, hand-tossed pizza. One customer from LaPorte, Indiana, wrote: "I have found my new old time favorite pizza place!!" For current prices, see our Our Menu page or visit our website for a quote.

The crust is the reason many regulars keep coming back. A Peoria, Illinois, customer described it this way: "The hand-tossed dough melts in your mouth --light, airy and crispy on the edges." To learn more about how we make it, see Better flour makes a better crust, and read our local guide to order fresh pizza in Northwest Indiana.
Takeout, Delivery and Dietary Options at Indiana Pizzerias
Before you order from any pizzeria, ask about the practical details: whether the crust can be customized, how long delivery takes during your window, and what happens if an order arrives wrong. Ask about gluten-sensitive options and whether toppings can be customized for picky eaters. Those answers vary by location, so confirm them with the restaurant before you order.
Order Your Next Favorite Slice From Wana Pizza
Ready to order? Browse the full Wana Pizza menu with prices, from specialty pizzas and build-your-own pies to wings, calzones and dessert. Planning a team lunch or birthday party? Use our party order calculator to estimate how much pizza to order.
Ready to try a pizza worth the drive? Order from Wana Pizza today and taste the sweet sauce and garlic butter crust for yourself.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza place in Indiana?
No single pizza place is best for everyone, because the right choice depends on the style you want, your budget and how close you are to the restaurant. This guide groups standout Indiana pizzerias by what they do well, such as hand-tossed crusts, thin crust and family-friendly ordering. Check recent customer ratings on review platforms before you visit, since menus, hours and rankings change over time. For a crust-focused pick, start with a local favorite that matches the style you already enjoy.
Which pizza places in Indiana are best for thin-crust pizza?
Thin-crust pizza is one of the most common styles in Indiana, and many neighborhood pizzerias make it with a crisp, cracker-like base. Look for places whose menus name the crust style directly, and check recent reviews that mention crispness and how well the pizza holds up for takeout. Ask whether the crust can be ordered with customized toppings, since this matters for families with mixed preferences.
Where can I find the best pizza in downtown Indianapolis?
Downtown Indianapolis has a range of pizzerias to choose from. Compare current ratings, check whether the restaurant offers dine-in, takeout or delivery, and confirm hours before you go. Parking and walking distance can matter more than rankings for a weeknight dinner, so factor in your plans.
Can I customize pizza for dietary restrictions in Northwest Indiana?
Ask whether a pizzeria can adjust toppings, sauces and crust choices, since availability varies by location. Call ahead or check the menu notes before ordering if someone in your household has a gluten sensitivity or another restriction. Ask specifically how the pizza is prepared and whether a plain cheese or simple-topping option is available for picky eaters.